To optimally build strength and a better physique, just how “hard” should I train?
Is failure your friend? Let us kick off by setting the scene and asking, in the gym, what is failure?
Essentially, failure means doing an exercise until you cannot complete another rep, or until your form breaks down and you look like a complete shambles!
Training to failure is a bit of a hot topic in the fitness industry. There are typically two schools of thought around the subject,
- Less is more – we should have a couple of reps in the tank.
- More is more – any set not taken to failure is a waste of time.

But who is ‘right’?
Let’s look at the evidence. Are there people who have created fantastic physiques and built epic strength taking every set to failure?..absolutely!
But is “more is more” the optimal approach?
There are some significant downsides to taking every set to failure, such as causing significant fatigue in the muscles both during the session and after. For instance, if you’re bench pressing and intend on completing 4 sets to failure. In your first set, you are only able to complete 12 reps before failure, resulting in your next set failing at 7 reps, you are therefore working at less volume and most likely less stimulus than completing 2 sets of 10 reps at a lower weight.
Because of the fatigue, it feels like you have done more, but you have, in fact, done less over the full session. The same principle applies over a week. If you have a “monster sesh” on Monday, taking every set to failure, and as a result, you get yourself an extended tour of DOMS’ville (delayed onset of muscle soreness), come your next session on Wednesday you are so beat, you’re struggling to lift your protein shaker, never mind your desired weights. Over the week you have now done considerably less overall.
Add to this that fatigue can ruin your movement patterns and potentially lead to injury, training to total failure should be a tool to use when considered the overall long term view of your training, not just rocking up at the gym grabbing the dumbells and cranking out reps until you are shaking.

Stimulus vs Fatigue
The “game” we are playing when looking to create an effective program for you is the game of stimulus vs fatigue.
We are always looking to get the maximum stimulus during a session, and over a week and a block of training with minimum fatigue. And of course, the amount of stimulus required will be different from person to person.
What any well-thought-out program seeks to achieve is maximum stimulus with minimum fatigue, and therefore achieving more throughout a session.
The Research
Much of the older research on this topic did in fact prove that training to failure was more effective at building both strength and lean muscle, BUT (and a hefty but), they didn’t equate for volume. They didn’t look at how much weight was lifted overall in a session or week. And in later studies, when total volume WAS equated they actually discovered there wasn’t much difference.
As long as…and here is the pivotal principle, the sets were sufficiently difficult. What does that mean? It means we need to get within 2-3 reps of failure on isolation exercises (working predominantly 1 muscle at a time) and considerably less on a compound movement (multiple muscles used), such as squats, to get sufficient stimulus.
What Does This Mean For You?
In practical terms, the research suggests, for strength and building lean muscle, leaving a couple of reps in the tank will likely give you optimal benefits. But if you’re unsure, taking your last set on a particular muscle group to failure, will almost certainly cover all bases.
It’s all a matter of stimulus, fatigue, recovery, and overall volume over time. Anyone who has taken a set of squats to the point of total failure and I mean total failure, will know that the next set (if you can even do any), will probably be a right off, meaning you have in fact done less over the course of a week.
So Failure in training is a tool like everything else and should be selected from a ‘training box’ alongside a host of other considerations.
Final Thoughts
If you are wondering about whether taking your sets to failure is a good idea, or how close to failure is “optimal”, then I suggest leaving a couple of reps in the tank for the big movements like squats, bench press, deadlifts, etc, and 1 rep in the tank for isolation and accessory movements such as chest flys, lat raises and banded movements to get the optimum results.